The Long and Arduous Road from Toronto to Buffalo

Toronto to Buffalo Plan A

Ah the joys of trying to get from Toronto Canada to the United States on a Sunday. Bottom line, fly or travel on another day. Yes, it is only 100 miles, but crossing the border on land on a Sunday is not for the timid.

We wanted to fly into Toronto as it was a direct flight from San Francisco, go to Niagara-on-the-Lake and then go into the US to go to a conference in the Finger Lakes. Sounds reasonable, yes? Niagara-on-the-Lake is merely minutes by car to the US. The problem? Canadian car rental companies were unable to rent us a car in Canada and let us drive it across the border to return it to the United States. No one knew why the rules had recently changed, but they were. We were told that if we physically went to a car rental company in Canada and they had a US car, they MIGHT (and the operative word is might) let us rent the car and return it in the US. And yes, we tried every car rental agency in the area.

OK, let’s change the trip and start in Toronto and stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake on Saturday night. Surely there was a bus or something from there to the US as it was only minutes away. Wrong. Niagara-on-the-lake didn’t have any place to return a car rental. Plus, it didn’t have any transportation to the US.

No problem, there’s Uber….no, Uber can’t cross the border I was told.

OK, take a bus. Fine except the buses that ran from Toronto on a Sunday got into the US after the car rental companies closed for the day…that is unless we wanted to get a 6 AM bus, which Tom vetoed. Apparently car rental companies close to the border in the US don’t have sufficient traffic to open past noon or 1 PM on Sundays

OK, take a train. Drop the car at St Catherine’s, which is the closest train stop to the US and hop on the train. No, the St Catherine car rental agency was closed on Sunday and they didn’t allow after hours dropoffs. Really?

Surely the chamber of commerce in Niagara-on-the-Lake or in Toronto or in Buffalo knew a work-around. No. While they were amazed at the problems we ran into, and did their own research, they couldn’t find any alternatives either. The best advice I could get was to get a taxi to the Peace Bridge, walk across it, and then take a taxi to an open car rental company in the US. Sure, try doing that with 2 suitcases and a case of icewines.


Toronto to Buffalo Plan B

Joyce considers herself to be a problem solver. She worked on this issue from all angles and for hours, without finding an acceptable solution. She talked to many people, researched everything she could find, made phone calls. No dice. Travel to the US on a Sunday would not work.

Plan B was to fly into Toronto, drive to Niagara-on-the-Lake for a few days to check out the icewines. Then drive back to Toronto and stay a few days there. We then took an 8 PM bus from Toronto to Buffalo on Saturday night instead of Sunday. Once we got through customs, the 2 hour bus ride was really 3 hours, but who cared. We were finally back in the United States. After a quick but expensive cab ride to our Buffalo hotel, we finally got to bed around midnight. The next morning, Joyce went for a nice walk to pick up a car to continue the journey.

Whew. Persistence pays


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.